9 Johnston Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964
- 6 Rooms
- 4 Bedrooms
- 2 Bathrooms
- 1,850 Sqft
Single Family HIGHLIGHTS
Property Type
Single Family
Private Pool
Yes
Central AC
Yes
Pets Allowed
Dogs OK
Year Built
1964
Home Style
Ranch
Property Website
YEAR ROUND FURNISHED RENTAL Shelter Island 4 Bedroom Cottage with Gunite Pool and Hot Tub. 4 Bedrooms (Primary has King Bed with TV, guest bedrooms are all Queen Beds.) Two Full baths plus a seasonal outdoor shower. Restored 1960s ranch with a large cedar deck, pea-gravel driveway, hammock, and propane bbq grill. The house has a breezy nautical theme and a large record collection with great four-speaker sound and an upright piano. The windowed kitchen has a Bosch dishwasher, electric range, and plenty of counter space for cooking. Downstairs, there is a groovy media room with a new TV, another stereo with four speaker sound, ping pong, foosball washer/dryer, and four bikes for your enjoyment. The .6 acre lot is bordered by wooded vacant land on both sides, which allows for privacy and feeling close to nature. Very near to fabulous Sylvester Manor Farm, Hay Beach, the new Stars Cafe, and Coecles Harbor. No need to schlep your stuff back and forth, just leave it there. Dogs cases by case, no cats. Option to renew for second year possible.
Bathrooms Total
2
Bathrooms (Full)
2
Bedrooms Total
4
City Region
Shelter Island
Living Area
1,850 Sqft
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
Pool Features
Fenced, In Ground, Salt Water, Private
Private Pool
Yes
Property Type
Single Family
Year Built
1964
Architectural Style
Ranch
Construction Materials
Cedar
Levels
Two
Year Built
1964
Pets
Dogs OK
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
Borough
hamptons
Parking
Attached
Appliances
Electric Water Heater
Basement
Partial
Cooling
Yes - Central Air, Ductless
Furnished
Furnished
Has Basement
Yes
Heating
Yes - Baseboard, Oil
Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s), Chandelier, Sound System
Total Rooms
6
Water Source
Private, Well
Price and status history
- Nov 5, 2026Price reduced from $20,000$5,200
Similar homes that sold nearby
| Address | Size | Sold For |
|---|---|---|
| 69 North Cartwright Road,Shelter Island | 3 BR / 2 BA | $1,462,500 |
| 1 Gazon RoadShelter Island | 4 BR / 3 BA | $1,180,000 |
Closed sales recorded by Brown Harris Stevens agents.

Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY is a serene, secluded haven nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, accessible only by ferry.
Similar Listings
Request More Info
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.







