
The Hamptons
Shelter Island
Living in Shelter Island
40.9246° N 72.3548° W
Shelter Island, NY is a serene, secluded haven nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, accessible only by ferry. Its unspoiled beauty, quiet roads, and preserved natural spaces offer a peaceful escape from the bustle of the Hamptons. The Mashomack Preserve, covering nearly a third of the island, is a paradise for hiking, birdwatching, and kayaking. Charming inns, waterfront dining, and scenic beaches like Crescent Beach offer laid-back leisure. The island’s small-town vibe includes a historic village center, friendly shops, and local art galleries. Real estate ranges from quaint cottages to elegant waterfront estates, often passed down through generations. With a slower pace, rich history, and a deep appreciation for conservation, Shelter Island attracts those seeking nature, privacy, and a timeless coastal lifestyle. It’s a place where days are spent outdoors, evenings are quiet, and the beauty of the land and water is always close at hand.
The market today
24
Homes for sale
10
Rentals
$2,464,500
Median sale asking price
Available homes by listing type
- Sale24
- Lease10
Homes for sale in Shelter Island

Single Family | Shelter Island
20 Baldwin Road
$3,250,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 3,097 Sq Ft

Land | Shelter Island
9 Bay Shore Drive
$1,595,000
- Studio

Single Family | Shelter Island
11 Jaspa Road
$1,250,000
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,464 Sq Ft

Single Family | Shelter Island
17 Brander Parkway
$900,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 936 Sq Ft

Land | Shelter Island
2 Pandion Road
$2,800,000
- Studio
Curious what life in Shelter Island is like?
Our concierge knows the buildings, the blocks and the recent sales here, and it can tell you what your budget buys in Shelter Island today.

